Blog
/
Data-Driven Insights

How Accounting Mistakes Undermine Private Equity Fund Performance

How Accounting Mistakes Undermine Private Equity Fund Performance
July 8, 2025

Private equity fund managers are under increasing pressure to deliver strong after-tax returns amid volatile markets, rising interest rates, and tighter regulatory scrutiny. But one of the most overlooked threats to fund performance lies within the fund’s own back office: accounting errors.

Unlike operational missteps or missed investment opportunities, accounting mistakes often go unnoticed until they’ve caused real damage, distorted IRR calculations, delayed distributions, restated financials, or unexpected tax liabilities. In an environment where Limited Partners (LPs) expect institutional-grade reporting and regulators are sharpening their focus on fund structures, accounting is no longer a back-office concern. It’s a strategic priority.

According to the 2025 Preqin Global Alternatives Report, private equity assets under management (AUM) have surpassed $8.4 trillion globally. Yet a recent survey by BDO found that over half of U.S.-based private equity funds continue to rely on outdated accounting systems or underqualified internal teams. This gap between fund complexity and accounting sophistication exposes funds to material risk.

Why Accurate Accounting Matters More Than Ever in Today’s Private Equity Landscape

We're navigating a time of global instability, rising protectionism, and ongoing supply chain disruption. Domestically, the U.S. economy is teetering on the edge of recession. Interest rates remain high, inflation is sticky, and the Federal Reserve has yet to offer a clear long-term path forward. This uncertainty makes timing exits, raising capital, and allocating resources far more complex.

In this environment, minor accounting missteps can have amplified effects. Misreported management fees, inaccurate waterfall allocations, or outdated valuation methodologies may not only mislead LPs but also violate SEC expectations. Inaccurate accounting can also obscure the tax posture of a fund, leading to missed deductions or overpayments.

For funds trying to outperform in tight markets, precision matters. We’ve covered how volatility impacts distribution strategies in our guide to Overcoming Stable Instability: A 2025 Guide for Executives

4 Common Private Equity Accounting Errors That Threaten Returns

Accounting issues in private equity are rarely dramatic, but they’re frequently systemic. Most stem from insufficient expertise, poor integration of systems, or reactive processes. Here are 4 high-impact errors we encounter regularly: 

1. Misclassification of Management Fees and Carried Interest

Too many funds fail to distinguish properly between management fees, fund expenses, and carried interest, leading to incorrect capital account balances and flawed IRR calculations. This mistake is particularly dangerous when LPs audit fund performance or prepare to re-up.

2. Incorrect Waterfall Calculations

Waterfalls are complex, particularly with multiple classes of LPs, preferred returns, and GP catch-ups. An inaccurate waterfall model can underpay or overpay LPs or GPs, leading to clawback situations, reputational damage, and costly reconciliations.

We break down how waterfall structures can go wrong and how to fix them in our blog post on Private Equity Management: Five (Very) Expensive Mistakes

3. Delayed or Inaccurate K-1 Reporting

Failure to deliver accurate Schedule K-1s on time can frustrate LPs, delay their filings, and trigger state-level tax notices. This is especially common when funds operate across jurisdictions but lack centralized oversight.

4. Capital Account vs. Tax Basis Discrepancies

Many funds fail to properly track capital accounts and tax capital, leading to inconsistencies in gain allocations, confusion at exit, and increased IRS audit risk. With recent IRS focus on large partnership audits, these mismatches are becoming audit triggers.

For a real-world example of how to align tax and accounting, see our post on Tax Returns Services That Go Beyond Compliance

Accounting Compliance for Private Equity: What New Regulations Mean for Your Fund

Accounting in private equity isn’t just about accuracy; it’s about compliance. The IRS’s renewed funding, coupled with proposed rule changes from the SEC and FASB, has made accounting a regulatory hotspot. Here’s what’s changing:

  • The SEC’s proposed Private Fund Adviser Rules increase reporting requirements, mandating quarterly statements with performance, fees, and expenses.
  • The IRS Large Partnership Compliance (LPC) program now includes tiered private equity structures, increasing audit likelihood.
  • FASB continues to refine fair value measurement under ASC 820, particularly as it relates to Level 3 assets.

Funds that rely on legacy spreadsheets or quarterly reconciliations risk non-compliance. Regulators now expect real-time, auditable data integrity.

Want to know if your fund’s accounting systems are audit-ready? Our post on Moves in a Volatile Market outlines what auditors are targeting.

Poor Accounting Erodes LP Confidence and Fundraising Success

In private equity, relationships drive capital. One misreported capital call or delayed K-1 can damage trust, erode transparency, and create friction with LPs. Institutional investors, in particular, demand clean books and audit-ready financials.

Accounting errors, even if unintentional, signal weak internal controls. For GPs looking to raise subsequent funds, this can become a due diligence red flag. In an increasingly competitive fundraising market, clean accounting can be a differentiator.

Private Equity Fund Accounting Must Adapt to Multistate and International Complexity

Modern private equity funds often operate across state lines and international jurisdictions. But many managers still take a federal-first view of accounting and tax. That’s a costly oversight.

States like California, New York, and Texas have become more aggressive in asserting income and franchise tax nexus, even when the fund itself has limited presence. A remote employee or a subscription stream can be enough to trigger filing requirements. Inaccurate accounting of revenues by jurisdiction can result in penalties, interest, or amended filings.

International investments add further complexity: currency translation, foreign withholding taxes, and divergent GAAP standards must all be reconciled accurately. Funds that misclassify foreign tax credits or fail to report cross-border income correctly risk double taxation or treaty denial.

The Hidden Risk: Using the Wrong Advisors for Private Equity Accounting

Many private equity funds rely on generalist accountants or law firms to handle complex fund matters. This approach can be short-sighted. Traditional advisors often lack experience with fund-specific issues like carried interest, waterfall models, or multistate apportionment.

Worse, some funds delegate accounting to their fund administrator without oversight. While administrators are good at compliance, they’re rarely built for proactive risk management or scenario modeling. Without a strategic review, small errors go unnoticed until they balloon into audit issues.

What’s needed is a specialized advisor who understands the intricacies of private equity, keeps pace with evolving regulation, and treats accounting not as a cost center, but as a performance lever.

In a time of rising regulatory scrutiny and shrinking investor patience, clean books aren’t just compliance, they’re credibility. 

Conclusion: Strategic Accounting Is a Competitive Advantage for Private Equity Funds

In a world of shrinking margins and expanding oversight, accounting is no longer a routine obligation, it’s a competitive advantage. Mistakes in fund accounting are costly, but avoidable. By investing in expertise, integrating systems, and staying ahead of regulation, GPs can ensure they’re not just protecting value but creating it.

Don’t let outdated systems or underqualified advisors undermine your performance. The right partner makes all the difference.

At Parikh Financial, we bring private equity accounting out of the shadows and into strategic focus. We combine deep technical knowledge of fund structures, tax mechanics, and multistate compliance with real-world insight into how funds function.

Contact us to learn how we can help your fund avoid costly mistakes and thrive.